{
 "updated": "2026-10-12",
 "note": "Tribunal reads v17 (2026-10-12), describing the record through the 10/9 night: 15 customs, 13 players, four of them draws on Midtown (three restarts and the 8:01 game the lobby quit; Kyle 10/12: draws and restarts keep their kills and deaths). CURRENCY RULE (Kyle's ruling, 8/1/26): no present-tense superlative unless it holds in 2026 or the last 90 days, and every career/all-time claim is labelled as career. 'The window' means the live last-90, cut 2026-07-11 through the newest night (2026-10-09), the same window as every board on the site (meta.recentSince). Written from dossier_evidence.py and data.js after the 10/10 refit, which RE-TUNED the model (half-life 400→90 days, worth 0.0146 log-loss): every rating moved, so receipts quote current strength as a POSITION, never points. A new ranked season (S10.5) started; most accounts are unplaced in it, so live ranks are quoted only where the tracker has one. Dgoldz is David, a new player (Kyle 10/12). HOUSE RULES: no signed rating points beside a name; no player singled out for a bad record; newcomers get the patient read. The card backs print each 'verdict'. Rewrite prose AND receipts every week, bump 'updated', then re-run build_site_data.py so the cards pick it up.",
 "players": {
  "Ice": {
   "form": "7-4 ON 10/9, the most wins in the lobby, with 280 kills, second only to Kyle. 59% across 112 window games (+5.0 against the odds), #1 in both the DPS Room and the Healer Room this window, and back to the model's #1 current rating.",
   "style": "68% DPS, 23% tank. His career role lines are level: 59% as DPS, 59% as tank, 56% as healer.",
   "working": "Hulk 43 window games at 56% (+4.0 against the odds his teams were given), Peni Parker 14 at 64% (+12.7), Black Panther 13 at 62%. Moon Knight is the volume: 51 games at 53% and the window's top Moon Knight damage (24.3k per 10).",
   "fix": "Doctor Strange 15 window games at 13% and Cyclops 19 at 35%: two side-picks running far under his line.",
   "blindspot": "The new ranked season (S10.5) just reset him to Diamond I live after a Grandmaster II finish in S10. The Celestial III on the ladder is a career peak from S2.5, not his rank.",
   "verdict": "Career 59% over 665, #1 Overall, and #1 on the model again. Two side-picks are the only leak.",
   "receipts": [
    "10/9: 7-4 (plus four draws), 280 kills / 73 deaths",
    "Window (last 90): 112 games, 59%, +5.0 vs the odds",
    "DPS Room #1 (33 pure games) · Healer Room #1 (12)",
    "Hulk 43g at 56% · Peni 14g at 64% · Doctor Strange 15g at 13% · Cyclops 19g at 35%",
    "Career: 665 games, 59%; 168 forty-kill games; 250 MVP · current strength #1 of 15 (after the 10/9 re-tune) · Overall #1"
   ]
  },
  "Kyle": {
   "form": "KILL CROWN, FOURTH WEEK RUNNING. 290 kills on 10/9, the most in the lobby, at 6-5 with four draws. 52% across 141 window games, and he carried Grandmaster III straight into the new S10.5 season.",
   "style": "63% DPS, 24% tank, 13% healer. #1 in the Tank Room this window (14 pure games, 22.6k absorbed per 10) and #3 in the DPS Room.",
   "working": "Iron Man 78 window games at 54%, Peni Parker 47 at 53%, and Jeff the Land Shark 35 at 53% with the best Jeff healing in the window (17.1k per 10).",
   "fix": "Namor 10 window games at 12% and Black Widow 6 at 17%.",
   "blindspot": "At all 85 group nights on record. His last 60 run at 46%, four under his career line, while the kill crowns keep coming: the output and the results have split for now.",
   "verdict": "Career 50% over 729, the most forty-kill games in the record (172) and the only 100-kill game. Four straight kill crowns and a Grandmaster rank that survived the reset.",
   "receipts": [
    "10/9: 6-5 (plus four draws), 290 kills / 57 deaths, most in the lobby",
    "Window (last 90): 141 games, 52%, −0.2 vs the odds",
    "Tank Room #1 · DPS Room #3 this window · Iron Man 78g at 54% · Jeff 35g at 53%",
    "Live rank Grandmaster III (S10.5)",
    "Career: 729 games, 50%; 172 forty-kill games (#1); 85 of 85 group nights · current strength #5 of 15 (after the 10/9 re-tune) · Overall #2"
   ]
  },
  "Michael": {
   "form": "5-6 ON 10/9 with 225 kills, third in the lobby. 52% across 99 window games, #2 in both the DPS Room and the Healer Room, and the model's #3 current rating.",
   "style": "44% healer, 31% tank, 25% DPS: still the one true three-role regular. Career 65% as healer.",
   "working": "Adam Warlock 36 window games at 55% (+4.1 against the odds); Gambit 38 at 24.3k heals per 10, the biggest healing line in the window.",
   "fix": "Black Widow 42 window games at 39% (−12.9) and Spider-Man 26 at 38% (−11.4).",
   "blindspot": "His last 60 are 52%, four under a 56% career: form, not a verdict. Not placed yet in S10.5, so the rank quarter of his Overall is provisional and he slid to #5 on the standings while the lens waits.",
   "verdict": "Career 56% over 589 and #3 on the model. Warlock is winning; Widow and Spider-Man are where the record leaks.",
   "receipts": [
    "10/9: 5-6 (plus four draws), 225 kills / 62 deaths",
    "Window (last 90): 99 games, 52%, −0.4 vs the odds",
    "DPS Room #2 · Healer Room #2 (19.6k heals/10)",
    "Warlock 36g at 55% · Black Widow 42g at 39% · Spider-Man 26g at 38%",
    "Career: 589 games, 56% · current strength #3 of 15 (after the 10/9 re-tune) · Overall #5"
   ]
  },
  "Zach S.": {
   "form": "4-7 ON 10/9 with 154 kills. His last 60 run at 48%, one over his career line; the 90-day window is 42% over 121.",
   "style": "43% DPS, 36% healer, 21% tank. #3 in the Healer Room and #3 in the Tank Room this window.",
   "working": "Doctor Strange 22 window games at 55% (+6.4), Peni Parker 27 at 50%. His Cloak & Dagger healing is the best of anyone who plays it (20.3k per 10).",
   "fix": "That Cloak & Dagger output wins 32% of 39 window games (−13.7), and Star-Lord is 43 at 37% (−10.1).",
   "blindspot": "82 of 85 group nights. Not placed yet in S10.5, so his Overall sits on three lenses for now.",
   "verdict": "Career 47% over 706 and a top-three healer this quarter. The output is on Cloak & Dagger; the wins are on Strange and Peni.",
   "receipts": [
    "10/9: 4-7 (plus four draws), 154 kills / 92 deaths",
    "Window (last 90): 121 games, 42%, −4.4 vs the odds",
    "Doctor Strange 22g at 55% · Peni 27g at 50% · Cloak & Dagger 39g at 32%",
    "Healer Room #3 · Tank Room #3 this window · 82 of 85 group nights",
    "Career: 706 games, 47%; 97 forty-kill games · current strength #10 of 15 (after the 10/9 re-tune) · Overall #8"
   ]
  },
  "Donovan": {
   "form": "6-5 ON 10/9 with 174 kills. 56% across 110 window games (+7.1 against the odds) on a 45% career, and the model's #7 current rating.",
   "style": "36% DPS, 35% healer, 28% tank: a genuine flex. Healer Room #6 and DPS #7 this window.",
   "working": "Winter Soldier 16 window games at 75% (+32.1), Cloak & Dagger 26 at 60% (+9.1), Squirrel Girl 22 at 55%, Thor 37 at 53%.",
   "fix": "Mantis 18 window games at 29% and Namor 22 at 40%.",
   "blindspot": "His last 60 run seven points over his career line, the biggest current lift among the long-time regulars. Not placed yet in S10.5.",
   "verdict": "Career 45%, window 56%, and well ahead of his odds this quarter. Winter Soldier and Cloak are where it's coming from.",
   "receipts": [
    "10/9: 6-5 (plus four draws), 174 kills / 87 deaths",
    "Window (last 90): 110 games, 56%, +7.1 vs the odds",
    "Winter Soldier 16g at 75% · Cloak & Dagger 26g at 60% · Mantis 18g at 29%",
    "Last 60: 52%, +7 on his career line",
    "Career: 641 games, 45% · current strength #7 of 15 (after the 10/9 re-tune) · Overall #9"
   ]
  },
  "Tomas": {
   "form": "3-3 ON 10/9 across the first ten games, with 133 kills. 54% across 107 window games (+2.5 against the odds) on a 48% career, and 54% over his last 60. The model's #4.",
   "style": "84% DPS. The Punisher and Namor are most of his games.",
   "working": "The Punisher 49 window games at 59% (+8.9) with the window's top Punisher damage (17.2k per 10), Rocket Raccoon 36 at 64% (+11.0).",
   "fix": "Iron Man 27 window games at 36% (−12.3).",
   "blindspot": "Platinum I live in S10.5 after a Diamond II S10 and a career peak of Grandmaster III: a season reset, not a slump. Up to #4 Overall this week.",
   "verdict": "Career 48%, window 54%. The Punisher and Rocket carry it; Iron Man gives some back.",
   "receipts": [
    "10/9: 3-3 (plus four draws), 133 kills / 47 deaths",
    "Window (last 90): 107 games, 54%, +2.5 vs the odds",
    "The Punisher 49g at 59% · Rocket 36g at 64% · Iron Man 27g at 36%",
    "Live rank Platinum I (S10.5)",
    "Career: 516 games, 48% · current strength #4 of 15 (after the 10/9 re-tune) · Overall #4"
   ]
  },
  "Justin Cano": {
   "form": "SAT OUT 10/9. 47% across 46 window games; his healing still leads the lobby: 15,500 a game over his last 60.",
   "style": "68% DPS and 29% healer over his career, but a healer first this window (31 of his pure games, Healer Room #5).",
   "working": "The Punisher 8 window games at 62% (+16.3 against the odds), Moon Knight 9 at 56%.",
   "fix": "Cloak & Dagger 32 window games at 40%.",
   "blindspot": "Plays across two accounts, neither with ranked games.",
   "verdict": "Career 47% over 331. The healing is real; the wins still live on The Punisher.",
   "receipts": [
    "Window (last 90): 46 games, 47%, +1.1 vs the odds",
    "15,500 healing a game over his last 60, the lobby's #1",
    "The Punisher 8g at 62% · Cloak & Dagger 32g at 40%",
    "Career: 331 games, 47%",
    "Current strength #8 of 15 (after the 10/9 re-tune) · Overall #13"
   ]
  },
  "Zion": {
   "form": "FOURTEEN GAMES ON 10/9 with 131 kills, eleven of them on Jeff. 33 window games, all as the lobby's volunteer healer.",
   "style": "93% healer, by choice: the lobby's original volunteer.",
   "working": "Ultron: 28 career games at 48%, his best second option. Career, he is the lobby's #1 Jeff the Land Shark (212 games).",
   "fix": "The window has been hard on Jeff: 26 games at 29%, well under his 49% career on him.",
   "blindspot": "8 ranked games, so no rank to score. Two long nights in a row (25 games across 10/2 and 10/9) are most of his window.",
   "verdict": "Career 48% over 274 and the most committed healer in the record.",
   "receipts": [
    "10/9: 131 kills / 69 deaths across fourteen games",
    "Window (last 90): 33 games",
    "Jeff 26g in the window · Ultron 28g career at 48%",
    "93% of his playtime at healer",
    "Current strength #15 of 15 (after the 10/9 re-tune) · Overall #11"
   ]
  },
  "Bryan": {
   "form": "NO CURRENT READ. Last played 5/8/26, nothing in the window.",
   "style": "54% DPS, 32% tank across 186 career games.",
   "working": "Career: the hardest-hitting Namor in the lobby (17.3k damage per 10 over 61 games) and the top Punisher line too (18.9k per 10).",
   "fix": "Magneto: 35 career games at 26%.",
   "blindspot": "171 ranked games, none in recent seasons; career peak Gold II.",
   "verdict": "The heaviest hands of year one, and nothing to grade since May.",
   "receipts": [
    "Last played 5/8/26, no games in the window",
    "Career: 186 games, 48% · Overall #10",
    "Namor 61g, 17.3k dmg/10 (lobby's #1) · The Punisher 18g, 18.9k dmg/10",
    "Magneto 35g at 26%",
    "Career peak Gold II · no current strength (no recent games)"
   ]
  },
  "Alan Buenos": {
   "form": "SAT OUT 10/9. 52% across 33 window games, +5.7 against the odds his teams were given, on a 47% career.",
   "style": "72% healer, by reflex.",
   "working": "Invisible Woman 24 window games at 55% (+8.5): a real main now.",
   "fix": "The per-10 healing trails the wins: #11 of 12 in the Healer Room this window (12.0k heals per 10).",
   "blindspot": "52 ranked games; Bronze II in S10 after a Silver III S9.5, not placed yet in S10.5.",
   "verdict": "Career 47% over 201, window 52% and ahead of his odds. Up to #6 Overall.",
   "receipts": [
    "Window (last 90): 33 games, 52%, +5.7 vs the odds",
    "Invisible Woman 24g at 55%",
    "Healer Room #11 of 12 this window (12.0k heals/10)",
    "Career: 201 games, 47%",
    "Current strength #9 of 15 (after the 10/9 re-tune) · Overall #6"
   ]
  },
  "Mo Mo": {
   "form": "5-3 ON 10/9, half the night on Rocket. 58% across 50 window games (+10.3 against the odds), and up to the model's #6 current rating.",
   "style": "71% DPS, 26% healer: Squirrel Girl and Rocket Raccoon, almost nothing else.",
   "working": "Rocket Raccoon 22 window games at 68% (+18.9) with the window's best Rocket healing (17.5k per 10); Squirrel Girl 27 at 57% (+10.7) with the window's top Squirrel Girl damage (15.4k per 10).",
   "fix": "Nothing under his line with volume this window. Career, Namor (10 games at 29%) is the one to leave alone.",
   "blindspot": "No ranked games, so his Overall runs without the rank lens.",
   "verdict": "Career 46% over 117 and the best window of his record. Rocket and Squirrel Girl are both winning.",
   "receipts": [
    "10/9: 5-3 (plus four draws)",
    "Window (last 90): 50 games, 58%, +10.3 vs the odds",
    "Rocket 22g at 68%, 17.5k heals/10 · Squirrel Girl 27g at 57%, 15.4k dmg/10",
    "Career: 117 games, 46%",
    "Current strength #6 of 15 (after the 10/9 re-tune) · Overall #16"
   ]
  },
  "Jonathan": {
   "form": "SAT OUT 10/9. 40% across 67 window games, and past the 50-ranked-game bar, so the rank quarter of his Overall counts.",
   "style": "55% tank, 28% DPS. The Hood is his main: 57 window games.",
   "working": "The Punisher 14 window games at 50%. Gold II in S10.",
   "fix": "Black Widow 14 window games at 23% (−20.6 against the odds).",
   "blindspot": "#7 Overall without playing this week: other lines moved around him when the model re-tuned. Compare positions over a month.",
   "verdict": "The volume is real; the next step is a second hero that wins.",
   "receipts": [
    "Window (last 90): 67 games, 40%",
    "The Hood 57g at 43% · The Punisher 14g at 50% · Black Widow 14g at 23%",
    "67 ranked games · Gold II (S10)",
    "Current strength #11 of 15 (after the 10/9 re-tune) · Overall #7"
   ]
  },
  "Chris": {
   "form": "5-6 ON 10/9 with 197 kills, fourth in the lobby. 41% across 82 games, all inside the window.",
   "style": "53% DPS, 41% tank, and tank is where he is best: #2 in the Tank Room this window, with the most absorbed per 10 in the lobby (29.7k).",
   "working": "Namor 11 games at 50% (+3.9 against the odds); Devil Dinosaur 38 at 44%, his volume tank.",
   "fix": "Phoenix 30 games at 36% (−13.2).",
   "blindspot": "Opened at the harshest debut rating on record on 8/14 and has climbed since. Rated since 8/31.",
   "verdict": "On tank he soaks more damage per 10 minutes than anyone in the lobby (#1 in the Tank Room this window), and his record is still catching up.",
   "receipts": [
    "10/9: 5-6 (plus four draws), 197 kills / 73 deaths",
    "Career (all in window): 82 games, 41%",
    "Tank Room #2 · 29.7k absorbed/10, the lobby's most",
    "Namor 11g at 50% · Devil Dinosaur 38g at 44% · Phoenix 30g at 36%",
    "Rated since 8/31 · current strength #12 of 15 (after the 10/9 re-tune) · Overall #14"
   ]
  },
  "Joe": {
   "form": "SAT OUT 10/9. Rated since 9/24: 31 games across four nights.",
   "style": "48% DPS, 42% healer.",
   "working": "Thor: 6 games at 83% (+35.1 against the odds). Small, and the best line on his card.",
   "fix": "Adam Warlock 14 games at 29% and Star-Lord 7 at 14%.",
   "blindspot": "The IGN is theprodigaljoe, and the tracker trail runs back to 2025.",
   "verdict": "Four nights in. Thor is the pick the record likes.",
   "receipts": [
    "Career (all in window): 31 games, 38%",
    "Thor 6g at 83% · Spider-Man 16g at 40% · Warlock 14g at 29%",
    "Rated since 9/24: every newcomer starts near the bottom and climbs · Overall #12"
   ]
  },
  "Melo": {
   "form": "4-4 ON 10/9 with 190 kills on 48 deaths. 62% across 47 games and the model's #2 current rating after its re-tune.",
   "style": "84% tank that kills like a duelist.",
   "working": "Venom 26 games at 60% (+9.9 against the odds), The Hood 25 at 58% (+10.0), Magneto 9 at 67%.",
   "fix": "Nothing under his line now: Jubilee came back to 50% over 11.",
   "blindspot": "Five nights of evidence and 13 ranked games, under the 50-game bar, so his Overall runs on three lenses. The rating is real but young.",
   "verdict": "Five nights in: #2 on the model and #3 Overall, 62% over 47. Keep showing up.",
   "receipts": [
    "10/9: 4-4 (plus four draws), 190 kills / 48 deaths",
    "Career (all in window): 47 games, 62%",
    "Venom 26g at 60% · The Hood 25g at 58%",
    "Tank Room #4 this window (33 pure games)",
    "Current strength #2 of 15 (after the 10/9 re-tune) · Overall #3"
   ]
  },
  "Jared": {
   "form": "SAT OUT 10/9. Rated since 9/24, starting low, which is where every newcomer starts and climbs from.",
   "style": "95% DPS; Squirrel Girl is 20 of his 24 games.",
   "working": "Squirrel Girl 20 games at 50%, with 14.3k damage per 10.",
   "fix": "The second hero. Nothing else has volume yet.",
   "blindspot": "His real account id was confirmed on 9/18; every game since is on one record.",
   "verdict": "0-4 to start, 45% since. The next few nights decide how far the rating moves.",
   "receipts": [
    "Career (all in window): 24 games, 45%",
    "Squirrel Girl 20g at 50%, 14.3k dmg/10",
    "Rated since 9/24: every newcomer starts near the bottom and climbs · Overall #17"
   ]
  },
  "Vinny": {
   "form": "6-0 ON 10/9, the best record of the night, with four draws and 104 kills on 34 deaths. His side beat the model's price again and again.",
   "style": "61% DPS, 30% tank. The Punisher is his main.",
   "working": "The Punisher 12 games at 55% (+5.8 against the odds) and a 2.81 career K/D.",
   "fix": "Magneto: 6 games at 20%. Small sample.",
   "blindspot": "Three nights now (9/4, 9/17, 10/9) and onto the standings at #15. The model hasn't rated him yet: his first two nights came with lopsided draws, and 10/9 pulled the other way.",
   "verdict": "Three nights in and the best record on 10/9. A few more and the number starts to mean something.",
   "receipts": [
    "10/9: 6-0 (plus four draws), 104 kills / 34 deaths, best record of the night",
    "Career: 25 games, 47%, across three nights",
    "The Punisher 12g at 55% · Magneto 6g at 20%",
    "Not rated yet: under twenty recent games · Overall #15"
   ]
  },
  "Thaer": {
   "form": "NO CURRENT READ. One night (9/4): 3-2 with 138 kills.",
   "style": "All five games at DPS.",
   "working": "A 2.65 K/D and 27.6 kills a game on debut.",
   "fix": "Nothing to fix on five games.",
   "blindspot": "Donovan's plus-one for the 4pm block. One night is one night.",
   "verdict": "A winning debut. Come back and the number starts to mean something.",
   "receipts": [
    "9/4: 3-2, 138 kills in five games",
    "Not rated yet: five games"
   ]
  },
  "Gomeh": {
   "form": "NO CURRENT READ. 10 games across two nights in August.",
   "style": "62% tank, 38% DPS.",
   "working": "Emma Frost: 6 games at 50%.",
   "fix": "Nothing with volume yet.",
   "blindspot": "Both nights were short ones.",
   "verdict": "The number moves the first night he plays a full one.",
   "receipts": [
    "Career: 10 games across two nights",
    "Emma Frost 6g at 50%",
    "Not rated yet: under twenty recent games"
   ]
  },
  "Sam": {
   "form": "NO CURRENT READ. 4 games in the window, 6 on record.",
   "style": "61% DPS, 35% healer.",
   "working": "Six games is a footnote.",
   "fix": "Come play.",
   "blindspot": "The BIGSPOOLIE account the audit flagged back in May.",
   "verdict": "Come play. Six games is a footnote.",
   "receipts": [
    "Career: 6 games",
    "Not rated yet"
   ]
  },
  "Cre": {
   "form": "SECOND NIGHT ON 10/9. Came in at 8:27 for the last five games: 2-3 with 51 kills, four of the five on Rocket Raccoon.",
   "style": "Half healer, half DPS so far: Rocket on 10/9 after Iron Man, Squirrel Girl and Magik on debut.",
   "working": "Rocket Raccoon: 52.2k healing across four games on 10/9.",
   "fix": "Nothing to fix on eight games.",
   "blindspot": "Two nights, both joined late. The account's tracked history is mostly from December 2024, so these are first customs with the group, not first games.",
   "verdict": "New, and here to play sometimes. Eight games is a hello, not a read: he starts low and climbs like every newcomer.",
   "receipts": [
    "10/9: 2-3, 51 kills / 38 deaths in the last five games",
    "Career: 8 games across 10/2 and 10/9",
    "Not rated yet: under twenty recent games"
   ]
  },
  "David": {
   "form": "DEBUT ON 10/9. Took the twelfth seat at 7:25 and stayed to the end: 5-1 with four draws and 121 kills on 36 deaths in ten games.",
   "style": "A flex from the first night: Squirrel Girl and Hela most, plus Rocket Raccoon and Hawkeye.",
   "working": "Ten games and only 36 deaths, with his side winning five of the six that had a result.",
   "fix": "Nothing to fix on one night.",
   "blindspot": "One night. His side beat the model's price, but that read is tangled up with Vinny's, who sat on the same side in most of those games.",
   "verdict": "New, and a strong first night. He starts low and climbs like every newcomer; a few more nights and the number starts to mean something.",
   "receipts": [
    "10/9: 5-1 (plus four draws), 121 kills / 36 deaths in ten games",
    "Not rated yet: one night"
   ]
  }
 }
}